1. "The (mis)use of evidence in contested rights: Commentary on the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls’ report on “prostitution and violence”.
- Author
-
Fried, Susana T, Miller, Alice M, Mallik, Rupsa, Radačić, Ivana, and Restrepo-Saldarriaga, Esteban
- Subjects
- *
VIOLENCE against women , *HUMAN rights workers , *RIGHT to health , *CRIMINAL law , *INTERNATIONAL law - Abstract
Plain language summaryOur article raises concerns about the basis on which a recent report on “prostitution and violence” by a UN human rights expert, rests its arguments. We wrote as researchers and advocates working around the world. We think that evidence is strong that criminal law making both the buying and selling of sex a crime hurts the very people who are most at risk. Our own work has also led us to engage with how inter-connected ideas about gender, race, age and sexuality matter to support rights for everyone. We also argue that “trafficking” is not the same as “sex work”. While we claim these ideas as a feminist approach, we know that there are researchers and advocates, including the author of the UN report, the Special Rapporteur on violence against women, who disagree with us.Because there is no agreement in international human rights law about what laws best protect the rights of people who sell sex, clear information by experts in the UN, where states debate law, are important. While there are often disagreements within the world of contested rights, we argue that independent experts’ reports should contribute to new law with accuracy and transparency. We say in our article that the SRVAW misuses evidence by inaccurately reflecting other UN experts’ work, especially on state responsibility for rights; not precisely presents facts; and ignores dissenting voices, such as sex workers of all genders and identities. We raise these concerns carefully in our article because we want to build the case for good practices to support the future of human rights, as human rights as a space of dignity and freedom are under attack. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF