Search

Small molecules can be discovered or engineered to bind tightly to biologically relevant proteins, and these molecules have proven to be powerful tools for both basic research and therapeutic applications. In many cases, detailed biophysical analyses of the intermolecular binding events are essential for improving the activity of the small molecules. These interactions can often be characterized as straightforward bimolecular binding events, and a variety of experimental and analytical techniques have been developed and refined to facilitate these analyses. Several investigators have recently synthesized heterodimeric molecules that are designed to bind simultaneously with two different proteins to form ternary complexes. These heterodimeric molecules often display compelling biological activity; however, they are difficult to characterize. The bimolecular interaction between one protein and the heterodimeric ligand (primary dissociation constant) can be determined by a number of methods. However, the interaction between that protein-ligand complex and the second protein (secondary dissociation constant) is more difficult to measure due to the noncovalent nature of the original protein-ligand complex. Consequently, these heterodimeric compounds are often characterized in terms of their activity, which is an experimentally dependent metric. We have developed a general quantitative mathematical model that can be used to measure both the primary (protein + ligand) and secondary (protein-ligand + protein) dissociation constants for heterodimeric small molecules. These values are largely independent of the experimental technique used and furthermore provide a direct measure of the thermodynamic stability of the ternary complexes that are formed. Fluorescence polarization and this model were used to characterize the heterodimeric molecule, SLFpYEEI, which binds to both FKBP12 and the Fyn SH2 domain, demonstrating that the model is useful for both predictive as well as ex post facto analytical applications.

We have developed a general method of making conditional alleles that allows the rapid and reversible regulation of specific proteins. A mouse line was produced in which proteins encoded by the endogenous glycogen synthase kinase-3 beta (GSK-3beta) gene are fused to an 89 amino acid tag, FRB*. FRB* causes the destabilization of GSK-3beta, producing a severe loss-of-function allele. In the presence of C20-MaRap, a highly specific, nontoxic, cell-permeable small molecule, GSK-3betaFRB* binds to the ubiquitously expressed FKBP12 protein. This interaction stabilizes GSK-3betaFRB* and restores both protein levels and activity. C20-MaRap-mediated stabilization is rapidly reversed by the addition of an FKBP12 binding competitor molecule. This technology may be applied to a wide range of FRB*-tagged mouse genes while retaining their native transcriptional control. Inducible stabilization could be valuable for many developmental and physiological studies and for drug target validation.

The cell-permeable dihydrofolate reductase inhibitor methotrexate was covalently linked to a ligand for the protein FKBP to create a bifunctional molecule called MTXSLF. The covalent tether between the two ligands was designed to be prohibitively short, so that unfavorable protein-protein interactions between DHFR and FKBP preclude formation of a trimeric complex. In vitro and in vivo experiments demonstrate that MTXSLF is an effective inhibitor of human DHFR, but that efficacy is decreased in the presence of human FKBP due to the high concentration of FKBP and its tight affinity for MTXSLF. MTXSLF also inhibits Plasmodium falciparum DHFR in vitro, but a low concentration of the weaker binding Plasmodium FKBP has no effect on the inhibitory potency of MTXSLF in vivo. These studies illustrate a potentially general strategy for modulating the biological activity of synthetic molecules that depends on the ligand-binding properties of a nontarget protein.

Ustiloxin D and phomopsin A are potent antimitotic agents that bind to tubulin and interfere with cellular microtubule function. A synthetic strategy has been developed to allow access to both of the natural products as well as a variety of variants of the ustiloxin and phomopsin family members in order to provide sufficient quantities for biological studies. Herein we report the enantioselective total synthesis of ustiloxin D using a longest linear sequence of 20 steps. Four of the five stereocenters were set using catalytic asymmetric methodologies. In particular, Evans's new Al-catalyzed asymmetric aldol reaction facilitated access to both syn and anti products corresponding to the different benzylic stereochemistries found in ustiloxins and phomopsins. In addition, due to its high functional group tolerance, Trost's Pd-mediated etherification was used to construct the chiral tertiary alkyl-aryl ether. Taken together, these synthetic strategies allow us to use densely functionalized intermediates to realize an efficient synthesis of ustiloxin D.

Bifunctional, heterodimeric compounds were synthesized to test their ability to create polyvalent arrays between DNA and microtubules in cells. Each dimer was examined for the capacity to bind to microtubules and for cytotoxicity against MES-SA and MES-SA/Dx5 cell lines.

A general strategy is described for improving the binding properties of small-molecule ligands to protein targets. A bifunctional molecule is created by chemically linking a ligand of interest to another small molecule that binds tightly to a second protein. When the ligand of interest is presented to the target protein by the second protein, additional protein-protein interactions outside of the ligand-binding sites serve either to increase or decrease the affinity of the binding event. We have applied this approach to an intractable target, the SH2 domain, and demonstrate a 3-fold enhancement over the natural peptide. This approach provides a way to modulate the potency and specificity of biologically active compounds.

The three-dimensional structures of parts of two enzymes that contain tandem Src homology 2 (SH2) domains have recently been determined. The structures suggest how the SH2 domains function in concert to regulate enzymatic activity and localization.

Src homology 2 (SH2) domains are phosphotyrosine binding modules found within many cytoplasmic proteins. A major function of SH2 domains is to bring about the physical assembly of signaling complexes. We now show that, in addition, simultaneous occupancy of both SH2 domains of the phosphotyrosine phosphatase SH-PTP2 (Syp, PTP 1D, PTP-2C) by a tethered peptide with two IRS-1-derived phosphorylation sites potently stimulates phosphatase activity. The concentration required for activation by the tethered peptide is 80-160-fold lower than either corresponding monophosphorylated peptide. Moreover, the diphosphorylated peptide stimulates catalytic activity 37-fold, compared with 9-16-fold for the monophosphorylated peptides. Mutational analyses of the SH2 domains of SH-PTP2 confirm that both SH2 domains participate in this effect. Binding studies with a tandem construct comprising the N- plus C-terminal SH2 domains show that the diphosphorylated peptide binds with 60-90-fold higher affinity than either monophosphorylated sequence. These results demonstrate that SH-PTP2 activity can be potently regulated by interacting via both of its SH2 domains with phosphoproteins having two cognate phosphorylation sites.

The cytoplasmic insulin receptor substrate-1 (IRS-1), which is multiply phosphorylated in vivo on tyrosine residues, is a known binding protein for the tandem src homology 2 (SH2) domain-containing protein tyrosine phosphatase, SH-PTP2. Eleven phosphotyrosyl (pY) peptides from IRS-1 were screened for allosteric activation of SH-PTP2 phosphatase activity toward phosphorylated, reduced, carboxyamidomethylated, and maleylated-lysozyme. Peptides IRS-1pY895, IRS-1pY1172, and IRS-1pY1222 showed up to 50-fold acceleration of dephosphorylation. Analyses of Arg to Lys mutants in either or both SH2 domains indicate that both the N-terminal (N-SH2) and C-terminal (C-SH2) domains function in allosteric activation. Direct determination by surface plasmon resonance of the dissociation constants between pY peptides and glutathione S-transferase fusions to N-SH2 and C-SH2 domains reveals a 240-fold preference of the N-SH2 domain (compared with the C-SH2 domain) for IRS-1pY1172. The N-SH2 domain prefers IRS-1pY1172 > IRS-1pY895 > IRS-1pY1222, whereas C-SH2 domain prefers IRS-1pY1222 > IRS-1pY895 > IRS-1pY1172. These data suggest that each SH2 domain can bind to a distinct pY sequence of multiply phosphorylated protein substrates such as IRS-1, while activating hydrolysis at a third pY sequence bound in the SH-PTP2 active site. In addition, proteolysis and truncation studies reveal an autoregulatory function for the C-terminal region of SH-PTP2. Limited tryptic cleavage within the C-terminus results in 27-fold activation of protein tyrosine phosphatase activity. The activated tryptic fragment cannot be further activated by pY peptide binding to the SH2 domains indicating that autoregulatory functions of the SH2 domains are dependent on the C-terminal region. These data suggest that multiple levels for control of SH-PTP2 enzymatic activity may exist in vitro and in vivo.

Dimerization and oligomerization are general biological control mechanisms contributing to the activation of cell membrane receptors, transcription factors, vesicle fusion proteins, and other classes of intra- and extracellular proteins. Cell permeable, synthetic ligands were devised that can be used to control the intracellular oligomerization of specific proteins. To demonstrate their utility, these ligands were used to induce intracellular oligomerization of cell surface receptors that lacked their transmembrane and extracellular regions but contained intracellular signaling domains. Addition of these ligands to cells in culture resulted in signal transmission and specific target gene activation. Monomeric forms of the ligands blocked the pathway. This method of ligand-regulated activation and termination of signaling pathways has the potential to be applied wherever precise control of a signal transduction pathway is desired.

Calcineurin, a Ca2+, calmodulin-dependent protein phosphatase, was recently found to bind with high affinity to two different immunosuppressant binding proteins (immunophilins) with absolute dependence on the presence of the immunosuppressants FK506 or cyclosporin A (CsA) [Liu et al. (1991) Cell 66, 807-815]. The binding affinities of the immunophilin-drug complexes toward calcineurin and the stoichiometry of the resultant multimeric complexes have now been determined, and structural elements of FK506, CsA, and calcineurin that are critical for mediating their interactions have been identified. Analogues of FK506 (FK520, FK523, 15-O-demethyl-FK520) and CsA (MeBm2t1-CsA and MeAla6-CsA) whose affinities for their cognate immunophilins do not correlate with their immunosuppressive activities have been prepared and evaluated in biochemical and cellular assays. We demonstrate a strong correlation between the ability of these analogues, when bound to their immunophilins, to inhibit the phosphatase activity of calcineurin and their ability to inhibit transcriptional activation by NF-AT, a T cell specific transcription factor that regulates IL-2 gene synthesis in human T cells. In addition, FKBP-FK506 and CyP-CsA do not inhibit members of the PP1, PP2A, and PP2C classes of serine/threonine phosphatases. These data suggest that calcineurin is the relevant cellular target of these immunosuppressive agents and is involved in Ca(2+)-dependent signal transduction pathways in, among others, T cells and mast cells.

Immunophilins, when complexed to immunosuppressive ligands, appear to inhibit signal transduction pathways that result in exocytosis and transcription. The solution structure of one of these, the human FK506 and rapamycin binding protein (FKBP), has been determined by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). FKBP has a previously unobserved antiparallel beta-sheet folding topology that results in a novel loop crossing and produces a large cavity lined by a conserved array of aromatic residues; this cavity serves as the rotamase active site and drug-binding pocket. There are other significant structural features (such as a protruding positively charged loop and an apparently flexible loop) that may be involved in the biological activity of FKBP.

The immunosuppressants FK506 and rapamycin bind to the same immunophilin, FK506 binding protein (FKBP), and inhibit distinct signal transduction pathways in T lymphocytes. A nonnatural immunophilin ligand, 506BD, which contains only the common structural elements of FK506 and rapamycin, was synthesized and found to be a high-affinity ligand of FKBP and a potent inhibitor of FKBP rotamase activity. Whereas 506BD does not interfere with T cell activation, it does block the immunosuppressive effects of both FK506 and rapamycin. Thus, the common immunophilin binding element of these immunosuppressants, which is responsible for rotamase inhibition, is fused to different effector elements, resulting in the inhibition of different signaling pathways. Inhibition of rotamase activity is an insufficient requirement for mediating these effects.