51. A 5-year (1990–1994) neuroblastoma screening feasibility study in France. Methodology and preliminary observations
- Author
-
D. Frappaz, L. David, M. Favrot, F. Chauvin, V. Combaret, Jacques Estève, M. Vercherat, P. Renaud, V. Fouillat, J. Greffe, M. Brunat-Mentigny, T. Philip, C. Lasset, and P. Mathieu
- Subjects
Pediatrics ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Urine ,AutoAnalyzer ,Neuroblastoma ,Vanilmandelic Acid ,chemistry.chemical_compound ,Predictive Value of Tests ,Reference Values ,medicine ,Neuroblastoma screening ,Humans ,Mass Screening ,False Positive Reactions ,False Negative Reactions ,Chromatography, High Pressure Liquid ,Creatinine ,business.industry ,Mortality rate ,Infant ,Obstetrics and Gynecology ,Homovanillic Acid ,medicine.disease ,Surgery ,chemistry ,Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child Health ,France ,business - Abstract
Introduction: Following the pioneering Japanese experience, several European and North American groups implemented pilot studies on screening infants for neuroblastoma, considering the possibility of demonstrating a decrease in mortality rate. In France, a 5-year (1990–1994) feasibility study on neuroblastoma screening at the age of 4 months was initiated in the Rhone district (1.5 M inhabitants, 26 000 births per year). Methods: Vanillyknandelic (VMA) and homovanillic (HVA) acids were measured by HPLC, and creatinine (Cr) by the Jaffe's kinetic method on Technicon RA-XT(™). VMA and HVA were expressed as μg/mg of Cr. The method was assessed with both a daily intra-laboratory control and a sample of urine obtained from a national quality control organism. Results and discussion: The overall participation rate for the 5-year period was 82.2%. Out of 105 293 infants tested from 128 126 births, 12 NB cases were discovered with screening (screened cases) and 1 case was discovered with a late performed test (at 13 months of age). Six neuroblastomas were found clinically before the age of 4 m. Two cases were missed because the parents did not perform the test. Three children with normal tests at screening were false-negative cases: two of them were found secreting at diagnosis, while one remained non-secretory at diagnosis and later on. Otherwise, thirty five false-positive tests were found. Biochemical observations are discussed. It is too early to reach clinical conclusions from this screening program on neuroblastoma as it is presently being followed up.
- Published
- 1996
- Full Text
- View/download PDF