Search

Two human Mu class glutathione transferases, hGST M1-1 and hGST M2-2, with high sequence identity (84%) exhibit a 100-fold difference in activities with the substrates aminochrome, 2-cyano-1,3-dimethyl-1-nitrosoguanidine (cyanoDMNG), and 1,2-dichloro-4-nitrobenzene (DCNB), hGST M2-2 being more efficient. A sequence alignment with the rat Mu class GST M3-3, an enzyme also showing high activities with aminochrome and DCNB, demonstrated an identical structural cluster of residues 164-168 in the alpha6-helices of rGST M3-3 and hGST M2-2, a motif unique among known sequences of human, rat, and mouse Mu class GSTs. A putative electrostatic network Arg107-Asp161-Arg165-Glu164(-Gln167) was identified based on the published three-dimensional structure of hGST M2-2. Corresponding variant residues of hGSTM1-1 (Leu165, Asp164, and Arg167) as well as the active site residue Ser209 were targeted for point mutations, introducing hGST M2-2 residues to the framework of hGST M1-1, to improve the activities with substrates characteristic of hGST M2-2. In addition, chimeric enzymes composed of hGST M1-1 and hGST M2-2 sequences were analyzed. The activity with 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB) was retained in all mutant enzymes, proving that they were catalytically competent, but none of the point mutations improved the activities with hGST M2-2 characteristic substrates. The chimeric enzymes showed that the structural determinants of these activities reside in domain II and that residue Arg165 in hGST M2-2 appears to be important for the reactions with cyanoDMNG and DCNB. A mutant, which contained all the hGST M2-2 residues of the putative electrostatic network, was still lacking one order of magnitude of the activities with the characteristic substrates of wild-type hGST M2-2. It was concluded that a limited set of point mutations is not sufficient, but that indirect secondary structural affects also contribute to the hGST M2-2 characteristic activities with aminochrome, cyanoDMNG, and DCNB.

A glutathione transferase (GST) mutant with four active-site substitutions (Phe(10)-->Pro/Ala(12)-->Trp/Leu(107)-->Phe/Leu(108)-->Arg) (C36) was isolated from a library of active-site mutants of human GST A1-1 by the combination of phage display and mechanism-based affinity adsorption [Hansson, Widersten and Mannervik (1997) Biochemistry 36, 11252-11260]. C36 was selected on the basis of its affinity for the transition-state analogue 1-(S-glutathionyl)-2,4, 6-trinitrocyclohexadienate. C36 affords a 10(5)-fold rate enhancement over the uncatalysed reaction between reduced glutathione and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB), as evidenced by the ratio between k(cat)/K(m) and the second-order rate constant k(2). The present study shows that C36 can evolve to an even higher catalytic efficiency by an additional site-specific mutation. Random mutations of the fifth active-site residue 208 allowed the identification of 18 variants, of which the mutant C36 Met(208)-->Cys proved to be the most active form. The altered activity was substrate selective such that the catalytic efficiency with CDNB and with 1-chloro-6-trifluoromethyl-2,4-dinitrobenzene were increased 2-3-fold, whereas the activity with ethacrynic acid was decreased by a factor of 8. The results show that a single-point mutation in the active site of an enzyme may modulate the catalytic activity without being directly involved as a functional group in the enzymic mechanism. Such limited modifications are relevant both to the natural evolution and the in vitro redesign of proteins for novel functions.

A library of variant enzymes was created by combined shuffling of the DNA encoding the human Mu class glutathione transferases GST M1-1 and GST M2-2. The parental GSTs are 84 % sequence identical at the protein level, but their specific activities with the substrates aminochrome and 2-cyano-1,3-dimethyl-1-nitrosoguanidine (cyanoDMNG) differ by more than 100-fold. Aminochrome is of particular interest as an oxidation product of dopamine and of possible significance in the etiology of Parkinson's disease, and cyanoDMNG is a model for genotoxic and potentially carcinogenic nitroso compounds. GST M2-2 has at least two orders of magnitude higher catalytic activity with both of the substrates than any of the other known GSTs, including GST M1-1. The DNA library of variant Mu class GST sequences contained "mosaic" structures composed of alternating segments of both parental sequences. All clones contained the 5'-end of a GST M1-1 clone optimized for high-level expression in Escherichia coli. The remainder of the sequences derived from segments of GST M2-2 and GST M1-1 DNA. All of the clones analyzed contained between two and seven distinct DNA segments. In addition, each clone contained an average of approximately one point mutation. None of the library clones analyzed was identical with either of the two parental structures. Variant GST sequences were expressed in E. coli, and their enzymatic activities with aminochrome, cyanoDMNG, and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB) were determined in bacterial lysates. Such screening of more than 70 clones demonstrated a continuous range of activities covering at least two orders of magnitude for each of the substrates. For a given clone, the activities with aminochrome and cyanoDMNG, in spite of their different chemistries, were clearly correlated, whereas no strong correlation was found with CDNB. This functional correlation suggests a common structural basis for the enzymatic mechanisms for conjugation of aminochrome and denitrosation of cyanoDMNG. From an evolutionary perspective, the results show that recombination of segments from homologous proteins gives rise to a large proportion of functionally competent proteins with a range of activities. The data support the proposal that natural evolution of protein functions may involve recombination of DNA segments followed by selection for advantageous functional properties of the resulting proteins. Clearly, the same approach can be utilized in the engineering of proteins displaying novel functions by in vitro evolution., (Copyright 1999 Academic Press.)

A library of active-site mutants has been constructed by targeting selected amino acid residues in human glutathione transferase (GST) A1-1 for random mutagenesis. The mutated residues are suitably positioned for interaction with the second, electrophilic substrate, in particular chloronitrobenzene derivatives undergoing SNAr reactions. DNA representing the GST A1-1 mutant library was fused with DNA encoding gene III protein, a component of the coat of filamentous phage. Phage display was used for affinity selection of GST A1-1 mutants with altered catalytic properties. The affinity ligand used was the sigma-complex of 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene and glutathione immobilized to Sepharose. The complex was designed to mimic the transition state of SNAr reactions catalyzed by GSTs. The selection system is based on the combination of affinity for the sigma-complex as well as the ability to promote its formation, thus mimicking two salient features of the assumed catalytic mechanism for the SNAr reactions. Many of the GST A1-1 mutants selected and analyzed contained an aromatic amino acid residue in one of the mutated positions, suggesting favorable interactions with the trinitrocyclohexadienate moiety of the affinity ligand. A mutant C36 was selected for more detailed studies. Its catalytic efficiency with several chloronitrobenzene substrates was 20-90-fold lower than that of wild-type GST A1-1, but fully comparable to naturally evolved GSTs of different classes, providing a 10(5)-fold rate enhancement over the uncatalyzed reaction. In the conjugation of ethacrynic acid, a Michael addition reaction, mutant C36 was 13-fold more efficient than the wild-type enzyme. Within experimental error, the quotient between the KF values for wild-type GST A1-1 and mutant C36 is the same as that between the kcat/KM values determined with 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene for the two enzyme forms. This result indicates that sigma-complex formation is rate-limiting for the catalyzed reaction. Thus, the principle of transition-state stabilization as a component of catalysis has been successfully exploited in affinity selection of catalytically competent GST A1-1 mutants. This mechanism-based procedure also selects for the ability to promote sigma-complex formation, and serves as a probe of the catalytic mechanism.