Search

In this paper, I will argue against the position of Carol Hay, who asserts that the oppressed have an obligation against oppression and that the bare minimum of this obligation is to resist internally. I will demonstrate that resisting internally leaves space for the oppressed to affirm the oppressors' false beliefs. Affirming the oppressor's false belief causes the oppressed person to disrespect themself. In order to understand why we must first understand what things contribute to our self-respect. Our ability to respect ourselves depends on many factors, but I will focus on two specifically. The first is our internal/self-image; this is how we see ourselves. The second is our external image; this is how we think people see us. One way we can disrespect ourselves is by causing conflict between these two elements, which undermines our self-respect. Hay's account is grounded on the oppressed person respecting themself. Therefore, if an oppressed person can disrespect themself while meeting the bare requirements of the duty to resist oppression, then we need to reconsider the bare minimum of the obligation to resist oppression.

In microbial fuel cells (MFCs), bacteria generate electricity by mediating the oxidation of organic compounds and transferring the resulting electrons to an anode electrode. The objectives of this study were to: 1) test the possibility of generating electricity in an MFC with rumen microorganisms as biocatalysts and cellulose as the electron donor, 2) analyze the composition of bacterial communities enriched in cellulose-fed MFCs, 3) determine the effect of various external resistances on power output and coulombic efficiency of cellulose-fed MFCs, 4) evaluate bacterial diversity and cellulose metabolism under different circuit loads, 5) assess the influence of methane formation on the performance of cellulose-fed MFCs under long-term operation, and 6) characterize the diversity of methanogens in cellulose-fed MFCs. The results demonstrate that electricity can be generated from cellulose by exploiting rumen microorganisms as biocatalysts. Cloning and analysis of 16S rRNA gene sequences indicated that the most predominant bacteria in the anode-attached consortia were related to Clostridium spp., while Comamonas spp. abounded in the suspended consortia. Results suggest that oxidation of metabolites with the anode as an electron sink was a rate limiting step in the conversion of cellulose to electricity in MFCs.This study also shows that the size of external resistance significantly affects the bacterial diversity and power output of MFCs. A maximum power density of 66 mW/m2 was achieved by the 20-ohm MFCs, while MFCs with 249, 480 and1000 ohms external resistances produced 57.5, 53 and 47 mW/m2, respectively. Thus the external resistance may be a useful tool to control microbial communities and consequently enhance performance of MFCs. Furthermore, this study demonstrates that methanogenesis competes with electricity generation at the early stages of MFC operation but operating conditions suppress methanogenic activity over time. The suppression of methanogenesis was accompanied by a decrease in the diversity of methanogens and changes in the concentration of short chain fatty acids.An improved understanding of the microbial communities, interspecies interactions and processes involved in electricity generation is essential to effectively design and control cellulose-fed MFCs for enhanced performance. In addition, technical and biological optimization is needed to maximize power output of these systems.