1. Non-right-handedness, male sex, and regional, network-specific, ventral occipito-temporal anomalous lateralization in adults with a history of reading disability.
- Author
-
Miller ZA, Hinkley LBN, Borghesani V, Mauer E, Shwe W, Mizuiri D, Bogley R, Mandelli ML, de Leon J, Pereira CW, Allen I, Houde J, Kramer J, Miller BL, Nagarajan SS, and Gorno-Tempini ML
- Abstract
Based on historic observations that children with reading disabilities were disproportionately both male and non-right-handed, and that early life insults of the left hemisphere were more frequent in boys and non-right-handed children, it was proposed that early focal neuronal injury disrupts typical patterns of motor hand and language dominance and in the process produces developmental dyslexia. To date, these theories remain controversial. We revisited these earliest theories in a contemporary manner, investigating demographics associated with reading disability, and in a subgroup with and without reading disability, compared structural imaging as well as patterns of activity during tasks of verb generation and non-word repetition using magnetoencephalography source imaging. In a large group of healthy aging adults (n = 282; average age 72.3), we assessed reading ability via the Adult Reading History Questionnaire and found that non-right-handedness and male sex significantly predicted endorsed reading disability. In a subset of participants from the larger cohort who endorsed reading disability (n = 14) and a group who denied reading disability (n = 22), we compared structural and functional imaging data. We failed to detect structural differences in volumetric brain morphometry analyses, however we observed decreased neural activity on magnetoencephalography within the reading disability group. The detected differences were largely restricted to left hemisphere ventral occipito-temporal and posterior-lateral temporal cortices, the visual word form area and middle temporal gyrus, regions implicated in developmental dyslexia. Moreover, these observed disruptions occurred in a focal, network-specific manner, preferentially disturbing the ventral/sight reading recognition pathway, resulting in a pattern of regional anomalous lateralization of function that distinguished the reading disability cohort from normal readers. Collectively, the results presented here align with old theories regarding the etiology of developmental dyslexia and highlight how results from investigating neurodevelopmental differences in healthy aging individuals can powerfully contribute towards our overall understanding of neurodevelopment and neurodiversity., Competing Interests: Declaration of competing interest ZAM reports no relevant disclosures. LBNH reports no relevant disclosures. VB reports no relevant disclosures. EM reports no relevant disclosures. WS reports no relevant disclosures. DM reports no relevant disclosures. RB reports no relevant disclosures. MLM reports no relevant disclosures. JD reports no relevant disclosures. CWP reports no relevant disclosures. IEA reports no relevant disclosures. JH reports no relevant disclosures. JHK reports no relevant disclosures. BLM reports serving on the Cambridge National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre advisory committee and its subunit, the Biomedical Research Unit in Dementia; serving as a board member for the American Brain Foundation; serving on John Douglas French Alzheimer's Foundation board of directors; serving on the Safely You board of directors; serving as scientific director for the Tau Consortium; serving as medical advisor for and receiving a grant from The Bluefield Project for Frontotemporal Dementia Research; serving as a consultant for Rainwater Charitable Foundation, Stanford Alzheimer's Disease Research Center, Buck Institute SAB, Larry L. Hillblom Foundation, University of Texas Center for Brain Health, University of Washington Alzheimer's Disease Research Center EAB, and Harvard University Alzheimer's Disease Research Center EAB; receiving royalties from Guilford Press, Cambridge University Press, Johns Hopkins Press, and Oxford University Press; serving as editor for Neurocase; serving as section editor for Frontiers in Neurology; and receiving grants P30 AG062422, P01 AG019724, R01 AG057234, and T32 AG023481 from the NIH. SSN reports no relevant disclosures. MLGT reports no relevant disclosures., (Copyright © 2024 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.)
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF