Harmony in a non-harmonic language: word order learning in French children

Recent studies using artificial language learning have arguedthat the cross-linguistic frequency of harmonic word orderpatterns–in which heads are ordered consistently before or af-ter dependents across syntactic categories–reflects a cognitivebias (Culbertson, Smolensky, & Legendre, 2012; Culbertson& Newport, 2015a). These studies suggest that English speak-ing adults and children favor harmonic orders of nouns anddifferent nominal modifiers (adjectives, numerals). However,because they target English learners, whose native languageis harmonic in the nominal domain (Num-Adj-N), this pref-erence may be based on transfer rather than a universal biasfor harmony. We present new evidence from French-speakingchildren, whose native language is non-harmonic in this do-main (Num-N-Adj). Our results reveal clear effects of nativelanguage transfer, but also evidence that a harmonic pattern isfavored even in this population of learners.