Modern and ancient geotherms beneath southern Africa

Estimates of subsurface temperatures in the Archean craton of southern Africa during the Archean derived from diamond thermobarometry studies are remarkably similar to temperatures estimated for the same depths today, even though heat production in the earth and the mean global heat flow were probably substantially higher in the Archean. We present multi-dimensional numerical models for the thermal environment of the Archean craton in southern Africa during the Archean in which deep mantle heat is diverted away from the craton toward the surrounding oceanic lithosphere by a lithospheric root beneath the craton. Extrapolation of present-day models to thermal conditions appropriate for the Archean is inadequate to explain the similarity of present-day and Archean temperatures in the cratonic root. Reconciliation of the modern and ancient temperature estimates requires either relaxation of the constraints that the cratonic crustal heat production and/or the earth's mean mantle temperature were higher in the Archean than they are today, or that substantial "erosion" of the lithosphere comprising the cratonic root has occurred since the Archean. The latter possibility could perhaps result from revolatilization of the cratonic root in association with thermal perturbations in the mantle, for which there is evidence in southern Africa in the form of post-Archean tectonic and igneous activity.