Comparison of turbulence models for powered-lift flow fields

The development of a practical turbulence model for the complex flows with strong streamline curvature associated with powered-lift aircraft was investigated. The approach was to modify existing models that were compatible with the widely used kappa-epsilon model already available in an existing 3D Navier-Stokes code. The state-of-the-art of current turbulence models was examined. Several models that provide curvature corrections to the kappa-epsilon model were numerically investigated. An algebraic Reynolds stress model, which provides additional physics, was also examined. Test cases including an impinging jet, an impinging jet in a crossflow, and two adjacent impinging jets with the resultant upwash fountain were calculated. The first two test cases could be modeled reasonsbly well with some of the models. The upwash fountain could not be modeled with sufficient accuracy, which is consistent with the findings of other investigators.