PROPERTY RIGHTS IN CHILDREN.

INTRODUCTION The Economics of the Baby Shortage, (1) by Elisabeth Landes and Richard Posner, described a suboptimal landscape of child adoption in the United States. Many children went unadopted, raised [...]
In 1978, Dr. Elisabeth Landes and then-Professor, later-Judge Richard Posner, published The Economics of the Baby Shortage. The article openly discussed how economic analysis can address the allocation of babies available for adoption. The ideas expressed in the article were widely denounced as an inhumane commodification of children, something tolerable only in the twisted minds of academic authors. Despite the backlash, an odd thing happened in the more than four decades since Landes and Posner wrote on this topic: their ideas began to take hold. Today, almost all states in the United States permit, in some form, the contractual assignment of parental rights; that is, almost all states now permit the sale of babies. We suggest, an ironic reason for the change: the modern technology of in vitro fertilization has quieted or overcome complaints about the commodification of children by moiling surrogacy contracts into a long-accepted, though euphemistically labeled, realm of parental property rights in children.