Comparison of human pluripotent stem cell differentiation protocols to generate neuroblastoma tumors

Abstract Neuroblastoma is the most common pediatric extracranial solid tumor and is derived from trunk neural crest cells (tNCC) and its progenitor sympathoadrenal (SA) cells. While human pluripotent stem cell (PSC) models of neuroblastoma have been described, the PSC were differentiated using protocols that made neural crest cells, but not specifically the trunk subtype. Here, we compared four recent protocols to differentiate pluripotent stem cells (PSC) toward SA cells and examined their efficiency at generating SA cells along with earlier cell states (neuromesodermal progenitors [NMP], tNCC), as well as generating MYCN-driven tumors. Interestingly, the protocols that created cells with the highest level of NMP markers did not produce cells with the highest tNCC or SA cell markers. We identified a protocol that consistently produced cells with the highest level of SA markers using two PSC lines of different genders. This protocol also generated tumors with the highest level of PHOX2B, a marker of neuroblastoma. Transcriptionally, however, each protocol generates tumors that resemble neuroblastoma. Two of the protocols repeatedly produced adrenergic neuroblastoma whereas the other two protocols were ambiguous. Thus, we identified a protocol that reliably generates adrenergic neuroblastoma.