Relative Merits of Optimal Estimation and Non-Linear Retrievals of Sea-Surface Temperature from MODIS

We compared the results of an Optimal Estimation (OE) based approach for the retrieval of the skin sea surface temperature (SSTskin) with those of the traditional non-linear sea surface temperature (NLSST) algorithm. The retrievals were from radiance measurements in two infrared channels of the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) on the NASA satellite Aqua. The OE used a reduced state vector of SST and total column water vapor (TCWV). The SST and atmospheric profiles of temperature and humidity from ERA5 provided prior knowledge, and we made reasonable assumptions about the variance of these fields. An atmospheric radiative transfer model was used as the forward model to simulate the MODIS measurements. The performances of the retrieval approaches were assessed by comparison with in situ measurements. We found that the OESST reduces the satellite–in situ bias, but mostly for retrievals with an already small bias between in situ and the prior SST. The OE approach generally fails to improve the SST retrieval when that difference is large. In such cases, the NLSST often provides a better estimate of the SST than the OE. The OESST also underperforms NLSST in areas that include large horizontal SST gradients.