Heavenly elliptic curves over quadratic fields

Motivated by a long-standing question of Ihara, we investigate heavenly abelian varieties -- abelian varieties defined over a number field $K$ that exhibit constrained $\ell$-adic Galois representations at some rational prime $\ell$. We demonstrate a finiteness result for heavenly elliptic curves where $\ell$ is fixed and the field of definition varies. Introducing the notion of a balanced heavenly abelian variety, characterized by the structure of its $\ell$-torsion as a group scheme, we show that all heavenly abelian varieties are balanced for sufficiently large $\ell$, with this result holding uniformly once the degree of the number field and the dimension of the abelian variety are fixed. We study the Frobenius traces on balanced heavenly elliptic curves, showing that they satisfy certain congruences modulo $\ell$ akin to those of elliptic curves with complex multiplication. Conjecturally, we propose that balanced elliptic curves over quadratic number fields must possess complex multiplication. Finally, we produce an explicit list of elliptic curves with irrational $j$-invariants, which contains all heavenly elliptic curves with complex multiplication defined over quadratic fields, supported by computational evidence that every curve on the list is heavenly.
Comment: 30 pages, 1 figure, 2 tables