SCR-22 of pollen-dominant S haplotype class is recessive to SCR-44 of pollen-recessive S haplotype class in Brassica rapa

SCR/SP11 encodes the male determinant of recognition specificity of self-incompatibility (SI) in Brassica species and is sporophytically expressed in the anther tapetum. Based on dominance relationships in pollen and nucleotide sequence similarity, the S haplotypes in Brassica have been classified as class I or class II, with class-I S haplotypes being dominant over class-II S haplotypes. Here, we revealed that S-22 in B. rapa belonging to class I is recessive to class-II S-44 and class-I S-36 in pollen, whereas it is dominant over S-60, S-40, and S-29 based on pollination tests. SCR/SP11 of S-22 (SCR-22) was sequenced, revealing that the deduced amino-acid sequence of SCR-22 has the longest C-terminal domain among the SCR/SP11 sequences. The expression of SCR-22 was found to be suppressed in S-22/S-44 and S-22/S-36 heterozygotes. Normal transcription of SCR-44 was considered to be due to the transcription suppression of Smi sRNA of the S-22 haplotype and a very low methylation state of the SCR-44 promoter region in the tapetum of S-22/S-44 heterozygotes. In SCR-22, only the cytosine residue located at the –37 bp position of the promoter region was hypermethylated in the tapetum of S-22/S-44 heterozygotes, and few methylated cytosines were detected in the promoter and coding regions of SCR-22 in S-22/S-36 heterozygotes. SCR-22 was also expressed in microspores in S-22 homozygotes but not in S-22/S-44 and S-22/S-36 heterozygotes. These results suggest that a mechanism different from class-II SCR/SP11 suppression may operate for the suppression of recessive class-I SCR-22 in S heterozygotes.
Self-incompatibility: Rethinking hierarchy Studies in cabbage plants shed new light on self-incompatibility mechanisms to avoid self-fertilization. In Brassica, self-incompatibility is controlled by the expression of dominant and recessive genetic variants in the S-locus region. These variants encode proteins that mediate the rejection of self-pollen, but little is known about how the dominance relationship is established between them. Takeshi Nishio at Tohoku University in Japan and colleagues have examined the sequence, expression pattern and dominance relationships of the gene encoding the pollen-coat protein SCR-22. Despite sharing features with dominant SCR variants, SCR-22 can act in a recessive manner. Interestingly, unlike other recessive SCR variants, the suppression of SCR-22 expression does not depend on the addition of methyl groups that prevent transcription factor binding. This finding suggests the dominance hierarchy is governed by different mechanisms.