Matrix Control of Periodontal Ligament Cell Activity Via Synthetic Hydrogel Scaffolds

Rebuilding the tooth-supporting tissues (periodontium) destroyed by periodontitis remains a clinical challenge. Periodontal ligament cells (PDLCs), multipotent cells within the periodontal ligament (PDL), differentiate and form new PDL and mineralized tissues (cementum and bone) during native tissue repair in response to specific extracellular matrix (ECM) cues. Thus, harnessing ECM cues to control PDLC activity ex vivo, and ultimately, to design a PDLC delivery vehicle for tissue regeneration is an important goal. In this study, poly(ethylene glycol) hydrogels were used as a synthetic PDL ECM to interrogate the roles of cell–matrix interactions and cell-mediated matrix remodeling in controlling PDLC activity. Results showed that PDLCs within matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-degradable hydrogels expressed key PDL matrix genes and showed a six to eightfold increase in alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity compared with PDLCs in nondegradable hydrogel controls. The increase in ALP activity, commonly considered an early marker of cementogenic/osteogenic differentiation, occurred independent of the presentation of the cell-binding ligand RGD or soluble media cues and remained elevated when inhibiting PDLC-matrix binding and intracellular tension. ALP activity was further increased in softer hydrogels regardless of degradability and was accompanied by an increase in PDLC volume. However, scaffolds that fostered PDLC ALP activity did not necessarily promote hydrogel ECM mineralization. Rather, matrix mineralization was greatest in stiffer, MMP-degradable hydrogels and required the presence of soluble media cues. These divergent outcomes illustrate the complexity of the PDLC response to ECM cues and the limitations of current scaffold materials. Nevertheless, key biomaterial design principles for controlling PDLC activity were identified for incorporation into scaffolds for periodontal tissue regeneration. IMPACT STATEMENT: Engineered scaffolds are an attractive approach for delivering periodontal ligament cells (PDLCs) to rebuild the tooth-supporting tissues. Replicating key extracellular matrix (ECM) cues within tissue engineered scaffolds may maximize PDLC potential. However, the identity of important ECM cues and how they can be harnessed to control PDLC activity is still unknown. In this study, matrix degradability, cell–matrix binding, and stiffness were varied using synthetic poly(ethylene glycol) hydrogels for three-dimensional PDLC culture. PDLCs exhibited dramatic and divergent responses to these cues, supporting further investigation of ECM-replicating scaffolds for control of PDLC behavior and periodontal tissue regeneration.