Comparison of Two Clinical Upper Motor Neuron Burden Rating Scales in ALS Using Quantitative Brain Imaging

Several clinical upper motor neuron burden scales (UMNSs) variably measure brain dysfunction in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Here, we compare relationship of two widely used clinical UMNSs in ALS (Penn and MGH UMNSs) with (a) neuroimaging markers of brain dysfunction and (b) neurological impairment status using the gold-standard functional measure, the revised ALS Functional Rating Scale (ALSFRS-R). MGH UMNS measures hyperreflexia alone, and Penn UMNS measures hyperreflexia, spasticity, and pseudobulbar affect. Twenty-eight ALS participants underwent both Penn and MGH UMNSs, at a matching time-point as a simultaneous [11C]PBR28 positron emission tomography (PBR28-PET)/Magnetic Resonance scan and ALSFRS-R. The two UMNSs were compared for localization and strength of association with neuroimaging markers of: (a) neuroinflammation, PBR28-PET and MR Spectroscopy metabolites (myo-inositol and choline) and (b) corticospinal axonal loss, fractional anisotropy (FA), and MR Spectroscopy metabolite (N-acetylaspartate). Among clinical UMN manifestations, segmental hyperreflexia, spasticity, and pseudobulbar affect occurred in 100, 43, and 18% ALS participants, respectively. Pseudobulbar affect did not map to any specific brain regional dysfunction, while hyperreflexia and spasticity subdomains significantly correlated and colocalized neurobiological changes to corticospinal pathways on whole brain voxel-wise analyses. Both UMNS total scores showed significant and similar strength of association with (a) neuroimaging changes (PBR28-PET, FA, MR Spectroscopy metabolites) in primary motor cortices and (b) severity of functional decline (ALSFRS-R). Hyperreflexia is the most frequent clinical UMN manifestation and correlates best with UMN molecular imaging changes in ALS. Among Penn UMNS's subdomains, hyperreflexia carries the weight of association with neuroimaging markers of biological changes in ALS. A clinical UMN scale comprising hyperreflexia items alone is clinically relevant and sufficient to predict the highest yield of molecular neuroimaging abnormalities in ALS.