Intra-laboratory assessment of a method for the detection of TiO2 nanoparticles present in sunscreens based on multi-detector asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation

In this study, an intra-laboratory assessment was carried out to establish the effectiveness of a method for the detection of TiO2 engineered nanoparticles (ENPs) present in sunscreen containing nano-scale TiO2 and a higher nanometer-range (approx. 200-500 nm) Ti02, as well as iron oxide particles. Three replicate measurements were performed on five separate days to generate the measurement uncertainties associated with the quantitative asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) measurement of the hydrodynamic radius r(h, mode1) (MALS), rh,,odei (ICP-MS), r(h, mode2) (ICP-MS), and calculated mass-based particle size distribution (d(10), d(50), d(90)). The validation study demonstrates that the analysis of TiO2 ENPs present in sunscreen by AF4 separation-multi detection produces quantitative data (mass-based particle size distribution) after applying the sample preparation method developed within the NanoDefine project with uncertainties based on the precision (u(IP)) of 3.9-8.8%. This method can, therefore, be considered as the method with a good precision. Finally, the bias data shows that the trueness of the method (u(t) = 5.5-52%) can only be taken as a proxy due to the lack of a sunscreen standard containing certified TiO2 ENPs.