Results of lumbar disk surgery in a city compensation population

This is a retrospective analysis of 118 patients who underwent 132 operations in a city compensation setting for the treatment of lumbar disk disease from January 1976 to December 1987. Each of these patients had a work-related injury. There was a minimum 2-year follow up with an average follow up of 6.9 years. No patients were lost to follow up. The purpose was to determine what percentage of patients treated in a work-related setting could be expected to return to a sustained, pre-injury employment state following a carefully executed lumbar spine surgical procedure. Satisfactory surgical results were considered achieved only by those patients who returned to full-duty work status. Only 31 of the 118 patients (26%) returned to full duty and were considered satisfactory. Regarding the number of surgical procedures, 31 of 132 operations (23%) were successful. Sixteen reoperations in 13 patients all resulted in failure. Only 16 of the 64 patients (25%) treated with laminectomy and diskectomy alone had a satisfactory result. When a two-level, posterior lateral spinal fusion was added the success rate was increased to 44%, with 12 of 27 patients returning to work. Six patients with spinal stenosis underwent decompression laminectomy and entry level foraminotomies, and all had unsatisfactory results. Five patients with isthmic spondylisthesis underwent a Gill procedure and fusion. Only one of these patients (25%) returned to work. For a 2-year period chymopapain injection was given to 14 patients. Only two returned to work, with a 14% success rate. Overall, the surgical treatment of lumbar disk disease in this group of city compensation patients resulted in a 74% rate of permanent disability.