Is a surgical resection leaving positive margins of benefit to the patient with locally advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: A comparative study using the intergroup study 0034 and the radiation therapy oncology group head and neck database

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine whether or not for patients with squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck, a surgical resection leaving positive margins followed by postoperative adjuvant therapy improves the outcome compared to a matched group of patients treated with definitive radiotherapy alone. Methods and Materials: From January 1985 through January 1990 a consortium of national cooperative groups (Radiation Therapy Oncology Group, Cancer and Leukemia Group B, Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group, Northern California Oncology Group, Southeast Group, and Southwest Oncology Group) conducted a phase III clinical trial testing the efficacy of adjuvant chemotherapy for patients with resectable, squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck. One hundred and nine patients were excluded from this study due to positive surgical margins. These patients have been followed prospectively with regards to local/regional tumor control, development of distant metastases, and survival. The postoperative treatment of these patients was not specified by the protocol but the majority of patients received postoperative radiotherapy ± chemotherapy. These patients were compared with a matched group of patients from the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group head and neck database of patients treated with definitive radiotherapy alone using a standard fractionation schema. Matching parameters included primary tumor site, T -stage, N -stage, Karnofsky performance status, and age. Results: Actuarial curves are presented for local/regional control and survival. At 4 years the local/regional control rate is 44% for the positive margin patients compared to 24% for the patients from the data base ( p = 0.007). However, there is no significant difference between the survival curves ( p = 0.76) with respective median survivals being 18.1 months vs. 17.9 months and 4-year survivals being 29% vs. 25%. Conclusion: While an incomplete excision followed by postoperative therapy does not seem to improve survival compared to treatment with radiotherapy alone, it appears to yield significantly better local/regional control. This would argue for its applicability in selected palliative settings. A follow-up, Phase III trial for patients with advanced tumors may be warranted to test traditional resectability criteria.