Effectiveness comparison between carbon spring and hinged ankle-foot orthoses in crouch gait treatment of children with diplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized crossover trial

BACKGROUND Children with cerebral palsy (CP) often present a loss of effectiveness of the plantarflexors/knee-extensors couple that leads to crouch gait. When treating a child with crouch gait by means of ankle foot orthoses, preserving or restoring push off power is a key issue. AIM To compare carbon-fiber spring (Carbon Ankle Seven® [CAFO], Ottobock® HealthCare, Duderstadt, Germany) and hinged ankle-foot orthoses (HAFO) effectiveness in improving functionality and walking ability in children with diplegic CP and crouch gait. DESIGN Randomized crossover trial. SETTING Hospital center. POPULATION Ten children with diplegic CP and crouch gait, 5 males and 5 females, aged 11 (4) years. METHODS The gait of each child was evaluated by means of instrumental gait analysis with both CAFO and HAFO, in a randomized order and after a 4-week adaptation period. The primary outcome measure was the change in ankle power generation. As secondary outcome measures, knee joint kinematics, stride length, walking speed, Observational Gait Scale, and preferred orthosis were considered. RESULTS The median of the energy produced in stance was superior with CAFO (+2.2 J/kg, IQR 4.7, P=0.006), and the energy absorbed inferior (-3.3 J/kg, IQR 4.3, P=0.011). No statistically significant difference was found for any other parameter. Preference of the children was equally distributed between the two orthoses. CONCLUSIONS No evident superiority of CAFO with respect to HAFO was found in improving gait performance of children with CP and crouch gait. Nevertheless, the results suggest the possibility that CAFO permits an energy saving and reduction of the more compromising deficits. CLINICAL REHABILITATION IMPACT The final choice of the participants indicates that CAFOs are preferred by older and heavier children, but the preference does not correlate with the performance of the orthoses during gait.