Back to Search Start Over

Three-tiered score for Ki-67 and p16ink4a improves accuracy and reproducibility of grading CIN lesions

Authors :
Renske D.M. Steenbergen
Annemiek Leeman
Peter J.F. Snijders
Marjolein van Zummeren
Maaike C G Bleeker
Wieke W. Kremer
Chris J.L.M. Meijer
Johannes Berkhof
Daniëlle A.M. Heideman
Miekel M. van de Sandt
David G. Jenkins
Wim Quint
Source :
Journal of Clinical Pathology
Publication Year :
2018
Publisher :
BMJ Publishing Group, 2018.

Abstract

AimsTo investigate the accuracy and reproducibility of a scoring system for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN1–3) based on immunohistochemical (IHC) biomarkers Ki-67 and p16ink4a.Methods115 cervical tissue specimens were reviewed by three expert gynaecopathologists and graded according to three strategies: (1) CIN grade based on H&E staining only; (2) immunoscore based on the cumulative score of Ki-67 and p16ink4a only (0–6); and (3) CIN grade based on H&E supported by non-objectified IHC 2 weeks after scoring 1 and 2. The majority consensus diagnosis of the CIN grade based on H&E supported by IHC was used as the Reference Standard. The proportion of test positives (accuracy) and the absolute agreements across pathologists (reproducibility) of the three grading strategies within each Reference Standard category were calculated.ResultsWe found that immunoscoring with positivity definition 6 yielded the highest proportion of test positives for Reference Standard CIN3 (95.5%), in combination with the lowest proportion of test positives in samples with CIN1 (1.8%). The proportion of test positives for CIN3 was significantly lower for sole H&E staining (81.8%) or combined H&E and IHC grading (84.8%) with positivity definition ≥CIN3. Immunoscore 6 also yielded high absolute agreements for CIN3 and CIN1, but the absolute agreement was low for CIN2.ConclusionsThe higher accuracy and reproducibility of the immunoscore opens the possibility of a more standardised and reproducible definition of CIN grade than conventional pathology practice, allowing a more accurate comparison of CIN-based management strategies and evaluation of new biomarkers to improve the understanding of progression of precancer from human papillomavirus infection to cancer.

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
14724146 and 00219746
Volume :
71
Issue :
11
Database :
OpenAIRE
Journal :
Journal of Clinical Pathology
Accession number :
edsair.doi.dedup.....86b1119ed680d75e8a705e6d0f7ba20e