A Hofmeister series perspective on the mixed micellization of cationic and non-ionic surfactants

Formulations for industrial applications are often mixtures of different surfactants and additives, including salts; thus, it is crucial to understand the reciprocal effects of the different components on the properties of the system such as cmc and morphology of the aggregates in solution. In this respect, we have studied the effects of anions occupying different positions within the so-called Hofmeister series, namely Cl−, Br−, SCN−, on the aggregation properties of mixtures containing a cationic and a non-ionic surfactant largely employed in formulation chemistry: dodecyltrimethyl ammonium bromide (DTAB) and pentaethylenglycol mono octyl ether (C8E5). We determined the cmc of the mixtures with different relative content of the two surfactants, as well as of pure DTAB and C8E5 systems, in water and in the presence of salts. Dynamic light scattering measurements were used to evaluate the hydrodynamic size of the aggregates, while small-angle neutron scattering to determine their morphology, as a function of increasing DTAB content, at constant salt concentration. We found no significant effect of salts on the cmc or aggregate dimensions of C8E5. On the other hand, increasing DTAB content, the salt effect is clearly detectable and ion-dependent: salt addition decreases the cmc in the order SCN− ≫ Br− > Cl−; moreover, halides seem to affect structural properties of mixed C8E5-DTAB systems very slightly whereas SCN− leads to a morphological change from a spherical to a cylindrical aggregate shape. Thus, this study well demonstrates how formulation properties can be fine-tuned by salt addition through a proper choice of ions species.