Three-Dimensional Radiological Assessment of Ablative Margins in Hepatocellular Carcinoma: Pilot Study of Overlay Fused CT/MRI Imaging with Automatic Registration

Background: We investigate the feasibility of image fusion application for ablative margin assessment in radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) and possible causes for a wrong initial evaluation of technical success through a side-by-side comparison. Methods: A total of 467 patients with 1100 HCCs who underwent RFA were reviewed retrospectively. Seventeen patients developed local tumor progressions (LTPs) (median size, 1.0 cm) despite initial judgments of successful ablation referring to contrast-enhanced images obtained in the 24 h after ablation. The ablative margins were reevaluated radiologically by overlaying fused images pre- and post-ablation. Results: The initial categorizations of the 17 LTPs had been grade A (absolutely curative) (n = 5) and grade B (relatively curative) (n = 12)
however, the reevaluation altered the response categories to eight grade C (margin-zero ablation) and nine grade D (existence of residual HCC). LTP occurred in eight patients re-graded as C within 4 to 30.3 months (median, 14.3) and in nine patients re-graded as D within 2.4 to 6.7 months (median, 4.2) (p = 0.006). Periablational hyperemia enhancements concealed all nine HCCs reevaluated as grade D. Conclusion: Side-by-side comparisons carry a risk of misleading diagnoses for LTP of HCC. Overlay fused imaging technology can be used to evaluate HCC ablative margin with high accuracy.