Current state of urethral tissue engineering

Urethrotomy remains the first-line therapy in the treatment of a urethral stricture despite data showing no real chance of a cure after repeated urethroplasties. An anastomotic or an augmentation urethroplasty with oral mucosa should be offered to patients with a failed urethrotomy. The availability of grafts can be a concern for both patients and surgeons. The potential for a tissue-engineered solution has been explored in recent years and is explored in this article.More than 80 preclinical studies have investigated a tissue-engineered approach for urethral reconstruction mostly using decellularized natural scaffolds with or without cell seeding. The animal models used in preclinical testing are not representative of disease processes seen with strictures in man. The available clinical studies were of small sample size and lacked control groups. The choice of biomaterial were mostly acellular matrices derived from natural extracellular matrix. The reported success rates in the pilot clinical studies were highly variable.The research with tissue engineering of the urethra has not yet been translated into a clinically available material. This is an area where much more research is needed and we would conclude that it is an area of unmet clinical need where users of tissue-engineered urethra in the future need to carry out a rigorous basic science programme and need to be cautious in drawing conclusions based on initial experience and report on long-term clinical results.