Diagnostic problems of evaluating vertebral metastasis from breast carcinoma with a higher degree of malignancy

BACKGROUND Bone metastases from breast carcinoma are frequently observed as postoperative pathologic conditions; however, in many cases, diagnosis and treatment are difficult. Although most diagnoses of bone metastases are made by plain radiography (X-P) or bone scintigraphy, the use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has enabled detailed imaging of foci, and many more lesions have become detectable. In the current study, the authors evaluated the relation between the diagnosis of bone metastases of breast carcinoma and clinicopathologic factors, especially those of proliferative activity and effects of treatment. METHODS The subjects consisted of 51 breast carcinoma patients (mean age, 51.2 years) with vertebral metastases diagnosed by plain radiography, bone scintigraphy, or MRI. Twenty-eight of the 51 patients were premenopausal and 27 of the 51 had bone metastases only. The patients were classified into the following groups: Group A, 24 patients who showed similar findings in plain radiography, bone scintigraphy, and MRI; Group C, 14 who showed no abnormalities on radiography or bone scintigraphy but whose lesions were diagnosed by MRI only; and Group B, 13 patients with findings intermediate between Groups A and C. The proliferative activity of tumors was evaluated by determining the level of DNA polymerase α. RESULTS Regarding the relation to clinicopathologic factors, a significant number of patients with estrogen receptor (ER) negative tumors who had a high level of DNA polymerase α, short disease free intervals (DFI), and metastases to other organs were included in Group C. Prognoses of patients in Group C were poor. CONCLUSIONS For the diagnosis of breast carcinoma with bone metastasis, different correlations were noted among the various biologic characteristics, such as ER status and proliferative activity. That is, bone scintigraphy sufficiently reflected foci in patients with ER positive tumors or tumors with low proliferation, whereas bone scintigraphy was false-negative in patients with ER negative or highly proliferative tumors, showing that MRI was useful in diagnosing such patients. Therefore, consideration of malignant features, such as proliferative activity and ER status, is believed necessary during the postoperative follow-up of breast carcinoma patients. Cancer 1999;85:1782–8. © 1999 American Cancer Society.