A Survey of Midwives in Quebec: What are Their Similarities and Differences?

Background Until recently, Canada was the only industrialized country that had not legalized midwifery. In the province of Quebec the government adopted a law to evaluate midwifery in eight pilot projects before generalizing the practice. This study examined the similarities and differences among midwives in Quebec. Methods Using data from a 1991 mail survey, we compared 31 nurse-midwives, 12 professional midwives, and 27 lay midwives to assess professional background and opinions about selected maternity care issues and aspects of future midwifery practice, such as midwife training options, responsibilities, setting for midwifery care, relationship to other maternity caregivers, autonomy, and control over their profession. Results Midwives largely shared the same philosophy of care but had different viewpoints on two main professional aspects: compared with professional midwives and nurse-midwives, lay midwives preferred to deliver antepartum, intrapartum, and postpartum care at a client's home or an independent birthing center; like professional midwives, they rejected nursing as a prerequisite to midwifery training. Other interrelated personal, social, political, and legal factors were also associated with different beliefs. Conclusions Despite the differences among the three groups, the process under way in Canada is to recognize a single profession of midwife. Creating a unified profession is a challenge that Canadian midwives with different backgrounds face in the 1990s.