Evaluating the surrogacy of multiple vaccine-induced immune response biomarkers in HIV vaccine trials

Summary Identifying biomarkers as surrogates for clinical endpoints in randomized vaccine trials is useful for reducing study duration and costs, relieving participants of unnecessary discomfort, and understanding vaccine-effect mechanism. In this article, we use risk models with multiple vaccine-induced immune response biomarkers to measure the causal association between a vaccine’s effects on these biomarkers and that on the clinical endpoint. In this setup, our main objective is to combine and select markers with high surrogacy from a list of many candidate markers, allowing us to get a more parsimonious model which can potentially increase the predictive quality of the true markers. To address the missing “potential” biomarker value if a subject receives placebo, we utilize the baseline immunogenicity predictor design augmented with a “closeout placebo vaccination” group. We then impute the missing potential marker values and conduct marker selection through a stepwise resampling and imputation method called stability selection. We test our proposed strategy under relevant simulation settings and on (partially simulated) biomarker data from a HIV vaccine trial (RV144).