Importance of Mobile Genetic Element Immunity in Numerically Abundant Trichodesmium Clades

The colony-forming cyanobacteria Trichodesmium spp. are considered one of the most important nitrogen-fixing genera in the warm, low nutrient, open ocean. Despite this central biogeochemical role, many questions about their evolution, physiology, and trophic interactions remain unanswered. To address these questions, we describe the genetic potential of the genus via significantly improved genomic assemblies of strains Trichodesmium thiebautii H94, Trichodesmium erythraeum 2175, and 17 new Trichodesmium metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs, >50% complete) from hand-picked, Trichodesmium colonies spanning the Atlantic Ocean. Phylogenomics identified ∼four N2 fixing clades of Trichodesmium across the transect, with T. thiebautii dominating the colony-specific reads. Pangenomic analyses showed that all T. thiebautii MAGs are enriched in defense mechanisms and encode a vertically inherited Type III-B Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats and associated protein-based immunity system (CRISPR-Cas hereafter). Surprisingly, this CRISPR-Cas system was absent in all T. erythraeum genomes and MAGs, vertically inherited by T. thiebautii, and correlated with increased signatures of horizontal gene transfer. Multiple lines of evidence indicate that the CRISPR-Cas system is functional in situ: 1. Trichodesmium CRISPR spacer sequences with 100% identical hits to field-assembled, putative phage genome fragments were identified, 2. High Trichodesmium spacer sequence variability indicating rapid adaptation, and 3. metaproteomic and transcriptomic expression analyses detecting the CRISPR-Cas system components in Trichodesmium colonies from the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans. These data suggest that phage or mobile genetic element immunity in T. thiebautii could contribute to their success, gene diversity, and numerical dominance over T. erythraeum in the oceans, thus warranting further Trichodesmium virome investigations.Significance statementOur work identifies CRISPR-Cas immunity as a phylogenetically distinct, environmentally expressed factor in the speciation of closely related N2-fixing Trichodesmium clades. These findings suggest that differential phage predation and resistance could be a previously overlooked selective pressure in the genus, potentially leading to the current numerical dominance of T. thiebautii over T. erythraeum in the oceans. Furthermore, while the currently CO2-limited T. erythraeum is expected to be a ‘winner’ of anthropogenic climate change, their predicted higher phage sensitivity than T. thiebautii could challenge this outcome.