Developmental-stage-specific proliferation and retinoblastoma genesis in RB-deficient human but not mouse cone precursors

Most retinoblastomas initiate in response to the inactivation of the RB1 gene and loss of functional RB protein. The tumors may form without additional genomic changes and develop after a pre-malignant retinoma phase. Despite this seemingly straightforward etiology, mouse models have not recapitulated the genetic, cellular, and stage-specific features of human retinoblastoma genesis. For example, whereas human retinoblastomas appear to derive from cone photoreceptor precursors, current mouse models develop tumors that derive from other retinal cell types. To investigate the basis of the human cone-specific oncogenesis, we compared developmental-stage-specific cone precursor responses to RB loss in human and murine retina cultures and in cone-specific Rb1 knockout mice. We report that RB-depleted maturing (ARR3+) but not immature (ARR3-) human cone precursors enter the cell cycle, proliferate, and form retinoblastoma-like lesions characterized by Flexner-Wintersteiner rosettes, then form low or non-proliferative pre-malignant retinoma-like lesions with fleurettes and high p16INK4A and p130 expression, and finally form highly proliferative retinoblastoma-like masses. In contrast, in murine retina, only RB-depleted immature (Arr3-) cone precursors entered the cell cycle and they failed to progress from S to M phase. Moreover, whereas the intrinsically highly expressed MDM2 and MYCN contribute to RB-depleted maturing (ARR3+) human cone precursor proliferation, ectopic MDM2 and Mycn promoted only immature (Arr3-) murine cone precursor cell cycle entry. These findings demonstrate that developmental-stage-specific as well as speciesand cell-type-specific features sensitize to RB1 inactivation and reveal the human cone precursors’ capacity to model retinoblastoma initiation, proliferation, pre-malignant arrest, and tumor growth.Significance StatementRetinoblastoma is a childhood tumor that forms in response to mutations in the RB1 gene and loss of functional RB protein. Prior studies suggested that retinoblastomas arise from cone photoreceptor precursors, whereas mouse models yield tumors deriving from other retinal cell types and lacking human retinoblastoma features. Here, we show that in cultured human retinae, retinoblastomas initiate from RB-depleted cone precursors that are in a specific maturation state and form pre-malignant “retinomas” prior to retinoblastoma lesions, as is believed to occur in retinoblastoma patients. In contrast, Rb-deficient mouse cone precursors of similar maturation state and supplemented with human-cone-precursor-specific oncoproteins fail to proliferate. Thus, human species-specific developmental features underlie retinoblastomagenesis and may challenge the production of accurate mouse retinoblastoma models.