High-throughput characterization of Lu-doped zirconia

Lu-doped zirconia (LuDZ) was reported in the 1960s to be a poor oxygen ion conductor. However, we identified this system as worthy of reexamination based on the results of a machine learning-based screen for promising oxygen ion conductors, further supported by a physical argument: because Lu is the heaviest and smallest of the lanthanides, it should offer the possibility of high conductivity due to its high polarizability and size compatibility with the zirconia structure. The relationship between dopant concentration and conductivity in the LuDZ system was determined using a high throughput experimental methodology in which spatially resolved conductivity was measured across a compositionally graded film, spanning from Zr0.93Lu0.07O1.965 to Zr0.82Lu0.18O1.91. The conductivity broadly peaks with composition at 15 cation % Lu, coinciding with the approximate phase boundary of the fully stabilized cubic phase. The composition-dependent conductivity measurements reveal a surprising increase in activation energy for ion transport with increasing Lu content with no change in this trend at the composition of the conductivity maximum. The pre-exponential factor increases sharply with Lu content, but displays a distinct plateau once the conductivity maximum composition is attained. At 500 °C, the conductivity of Zr0.85Lu0.15O1.925 is 2 × 10−3 S cm−1, approaching that of optimally doped Sc-stabilized zirconia, which has the highest reported conductivity among zirconia compounds. In comparison to other oxide ion conductors, Lu-stabilized zirconia offers the advantage over ceria of negligible electronic conductivity and is easier to process than (La,Sr)(Ga,Mg)O3-δ.