Nutrient losses after clearfelling in Beddgelert Forest: a comparison of the effects of conventional and whole-tree harvest on soil water chemistry

The effects of conventional, bole only harvesting (CH) and whole-tree harvesting (WTH) on major inorganic nutrient concentrations (K, NO3-N, NH4-N, PO4-P and Ca) in soil water are described from Beddgelert forest in North Wales. Monitoring of nutrient leaching losses, and the timing thereof, from brash through the soil and into streams draining the CH areas allowed assessments to be made of the value of brash as a nutrient source for second rotation crops. Most of the K (around 100 kg ha-1) and one-third of the P (10 out of 30 kg ha-1) leached out of the brash lying on the CH plots within one year of felling. A pulse of K passed through the soil profile, but less than half this K reached the streams. In contrast, the P was immobilized in the soil. The lack of brash resulted in the absence of K and P pulses on the WTH plots. On the CH plots, brash was a net sink for inorganic-N for 3 years after felling. However, in both CH and WTH, a pulse of nitrate was observed in the soil and also in streams draining CH areas. The source of this nitrate may have been death of fine tree roots, followed by rapid mineralization and nitrification. Calculation of a nutrient budget for a complete crop rotation indicates that P and Ca losses in harvested material are likely to result in long-term depletion of these elements, and that the effects will be significantly more severe if WTH is practised.