Pelmatozoan arms from the Middle Cambrian of Australia: bridging the gap between brachioles and brachials?

The early Middle Cambrian Monastery Creek Phosphorite (Beetle Creek Formation, Queensland, Australia) contains an assemblage of disarticulated echinoderm ossicles that are exquisitely preserved. Amongst this material we recognize pelmatozoan brachials, radials, basals and holomeric columnals. Although we cannot reconstruct the complete animal with precision, these elements represent the oldest known pelmatozoan with crinoid-like appendages. Key elements include isotomously to heterotomously branched uniserial appendage plates with a tripartite adoral food groove, a longitudinal central canal interpreted as housing entoneural nerve, and differentiated articulation facets. There are also epispire-bearing radials bearing one to four arm insertion-facets, each one pierced by a central neural canal. These canals run internal towards the oral area beneath the external food groove. Co-occuring material includes single truncated cone-shaped basals and holomeric columnals, both with a similar articulation pattern, and irregular, epispire-bearing thecal plates. This mosaic of crinozoan (uniserial isotomous to heterotomous arms with neural canal), blastozoan (epispire-bearing thecal plates, appendage leading to oral thecal food groove without direct connection with body cavity) and apomorphic characters (circumoral instead of basal entoneural plexus) is unexpected and demonstrates that crinoid-like pelmatozoans with uniserial, branched arms appeared significantly earlier than the Tremadocian, when the first articulated crinoid skeletons are found. It also raises questions about the polyphyletic appearance of feeding appendages among pelmatozoan echinoderms.