Isotopic and nutritional evidence for species- and site-specific responses to N deposition and elevated CO2in temperate forests

In this study we show that the effect of rising atmospheric CO2 levels on forest productivity is influenced by changes in nutrient availability caused by nitrogen (N) deposition. We used a dual-isotope approach (δ15N and δ13C), combined with dendrochronological and nutritional analyses, to evaluate the response of two dominant tree species in natural forest ecosystems near Mexico City (Pinus hartwegii—pine; Abies religiosa—fir). Our analysis focuses on changes that occurred over the past 50 years at two sites, one under high and one under low N deposition rates. Analyses of carbon isotope composition indicate increasing water-use efficiency in response to rising CO2 levels for both species and sites but this effect did not lead to improved tree growth. The magnitude and direction of shifts in 13C discrimination indicate a process of acclimation that varied with the rate of N deposition and species traits. Since the 1960s, strong negative responses to N deposition have been observed in fir trees, which showed altered foliar nutrition and growth decline, while the negative impacts of N deposition on pine trees remained undetectable until the 1990s. In recent years, both species have shown significant growth decline under high N deposition despite increasing atmospheric CO2. Multivariate analysis of leaf nutrients indicates that growth decline was prompted by depleted soil macronutrient (P, K, and Ca) and micronutrient (Cu, Fe, Zn, and Mn) availability. At both sites, fir trees were a better indicator of N deposition due to differences in canopy rainfall interception.