Do compensatory shoot growth and mycorrhizal symbionts act as competing above- and below-ground sinks after simulated grazing?

Since mycorrhizal symbionts are dependent on host carbon availability, shading and grazing of the host plant often decrease mycorrhizal colonization in host roots. We conducted field experiments on an intensively mycorrhizal host, Autumn gentian, Gentianella amarella to investigate the effects of neighbor removal and simulated grazing on host growth and reproduction as well as mycorrhizal colonization. In the neighbor removal experiment, we manually removed the above-ground parts of companion plants of gentians. Reduced competition tended to improve the performance of both the host and the symbionts. Total fungal as well as arbuscular, hyphal, and coiled hyphal colonizations were higher in gentians with neighbors removed. Simulated grazing (clipping off 50% of shoot height) reduced host shoot and seed biomass, whereas the responses of the root symbionts were most often positive or neutral. In the first experiment (with late-flowering plants), clipping increased arbuscular, hyphal, and total colonizations but decreased dark septate endophyte colonization. In the second experiment (with both early- and late-flowering plants), clipping did not affect total mycorrhizal colonization. Higher arbuscular, hyphal, and total colonizations were found in late-flowering gentians compared to early-flowering ones. Early-flowering plants, on the other hand, tolerated simulated grazing better compared to late-flowering plants, which may indicate a higher cost of the symbionts for the late-flowering plants. Above-ground herbivory tends to increase carbon limitation, and under these conditions, regrowing shoots and the fungal symbionts may appear as alternative, competing sinks for the host’s limited carbon reserves.