A Modified Approach to Fitting Relative Importance Networks.

Most researchers have estimated the edge weights for relative importance networks using a well-established measure of general dominance for multiple regression. This approach has several desirable properties including edge weights that represent R2 contributions, in-degree centralities that correspond to R2 for each item when using other items as predictors, and strong replicability. We endorse the continued use of relative importance networks and believe they have a valuable role in network psychometrics. However, to improve their utility, we introduce a modified approach that uses best-subsets regression as a preceding step to select an appropriate subset of predictors for each item. The benefits of this modification include: (a) computation time savings that can enable larger relative importance networks to be estimated, (b) a principled approach to edge selection that can significantly improve specificity, (c) the provision of a signed network if desired, (d) the potential use of the best-subsets regression approach for estimating Gaussian graphical models, and (e) possible generalization to best-subsets logistic regression for Ising models. We describe, evaluate, and demonstrate the proposed approach and discuss its strengths and limitations. The standard approach for fitting a relative importance network is to take each node of the network in turn as the dependent variable and run an all-possible-subsets regression using all of the other nodes as independent variables. With this approach, nodes are included as variables in the regression models even if they have little or no explanatory value. We propose a modification of the standard approach whereby best-subsets regression is used to select subsets of independent variables prior to running the all-possible-subsets regressions that estimate the relative importance network. The results of a simulation study showed that this modified approach leads to better recovery of the population-model relative importance network structure. The practical value of the modified approach is that a more parsimonious and interpretable network is obtained [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]