BOS, BES, AND BALONEY: RAISING KANE WITH BERNARDIN.

The article addresses the issue of using the behavioral observation scale (BOS) in evaluating employees. The author points out that while Bemardin and Kane present a number of criticisms of BOS as a method of performance appraisal, they do not cite psychometric data to support their criticisms. This note has shown that most of their criticisms are beset by conceptual problems, disagreements between the co-authors, disagreements within each author with what he said here versus what he has said elsewhere, and/or a disregard of previously established empirical findings.