Back to Search Start Over

A Tale of Two Envelopes.

Authors :
Katz, Bernard D.
Olin, Doris
Source :
Mind; Oct2007, Vol. 116 Issue 464, p903-926, 24p
Publication Year :
2007

Abstract

This paper deals with the two-envelope paradox. Two main formulations of the paradoxical reasoning are distinguished, which differ according to the partition of possibilities employed. We argue that in the first formulation the conditionals required for the utility assignment are problematic; the error is identified as a fallacy of conditional reasoning. We go on to consider the second formulation, where the epistemic status of certain singular propositions becomes relevant; our diagnosis is that the states considered do not exhaust the possibilities. Thus, on our approach to the paradox, the fallacy, in each formulation, is found in the reasoning underlying the relevant utility matrix; in both cases, the paradoxical argument goes astray before one gets to questions of probability or calculations of expected utility. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
00264423
Volume :
116
Issue :
464
Database :
Complementary Index
Journal :
Mind
Publication Type :
Academic Journal
Accession number :
27985620
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/fzm903