Tectonic Reorganization of the Caribbean Plate System in the Paleogene Driven by Farallon Slab Anchoring.

The tectonic configuration of the Caribbean plate is defined by inward‐dipping double subduction at its boundaries with the North American and Cocos plates. This geometry resulted from a Paleogene plate reorganization, which involved the abandonment of an older subduction system, the Great Arc of the Caribbean (GAC), and conversion into a transform margin during Lesser Antilles (LA) arc formation. Previous models suggest that a collision between the GAC and the Bahamas platform along the North American passive margin caused this event. However, geological and geophysical constraints from the Greater Antilles do not show a large‐scale compressional episode that should correspond to such a collision. We propose an alternative model for the evolution of the region where lower mantle penetration of the Farallon slab promotes the onset of subduction at the LA. We integrate tectonic constraints with seismic tomography to analyze the timing and dynamics of the reorganization, showing that the onset of LA subduction corresponds to the timing of Farallon/Cocos slab penetration. With numerical subduction models, we explore whether slab penetration constitutes a dynamically feasible set of mechanisms to initiate subduction in the overriding plate. In our models, when the first slab (Farallon/Cocos) enters the lower mantle, compressive stresses increase at the eastern margin of the upper plate, and a second subduction zone (LA) is initiated. The resulting first‐order slab geometries, timings, and kinematics compare well with plate reconstructions. More generally, similar slab dynamics may provide a mechanism not only for the Caribbean reorganization but also for other tectonic episodes throughout the Americas. Plain Language Summary: The Caribbean tectonic plate is bounded by subduction to the east and west. However, it is unclear how this plate configuration was achieved. Previous models suggest that the North American continental margin entered an ancient Caribbean subduction zone between 66 and 34 Mya, converting the margin to strike‐slip and initiating subduction to the east at the Lesser Antilles. However, the deformation expected for this event is absent at the site of the supposed collision. Considering geological and geophysical constraints across the Caribbean, we instead suggest that mantle processes drove the reorganization. Combining tomographic images of the mantle with plate modeling, we reconstruct subduction below the Caribbean. Then, through numerical mantle convection modeling, we simulate the Caribbean subduction setting at the time of the reorganization. Our results show that when a subducting plate enters the lower, higher viscosity part of the mantle, it affects mantle flow, causing compression in the overriding plate and the potential initiation of a second subduction zone. The timing when the first slab enters the lower mantle and subduction initiates aligns well with our reconstructions and geological constraints in the Caribbean. We hypothesize that a similar process may explain other major deformation episodes throughout the Americas. Key Points: Tectonic constraints conflict with previously proposed collision and escape models for Paleogene Caribbean reorganizationSlab reconstructions and geodynamic models suggest Farallon slab anchoring induced tectonic reorganizationIn this model, lower mantle slab penetration triggers mantle flow, lithospheric compression, and subduction initiation [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]