Reply to: Uncertainty and bias in Liggio et al. (2019) on CO2 emissions from oil sands operations.

Since synthetic crude oil production is reported monthly in inventories, we can scale flight measurements of CO SB 2 sb emissions (taken over several hours) to monthly estimates of CO SB 2 sb emissions and then correlate estimates of monthly CO SB 2 sb emissions to monthly synthetic crude oil production. Technical errors Fu and Legge assert that a single calculation error (not using the correct CO SB 2 sb /SO SB 2 sb molecular weight ratio) invalidates the results from the emissions estimation algorithm (TERRA). The CO SB 2 sb /SO SB 2 sb molecular weight ratio was used to provide a second and independent method for estimating/scaling up the CO SB 2 sb emissions from stacks to compare with the results using the TERRA algorithm. B replying to b L. Fu & A. H. Legge I Nature Communications i https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-40818-5 (2023) In our paper[1], we presented an aircraft measurement-based assessment of the CO SB 2 sb emissions from the oil sands surface mining sector in Alberta, Canada, and demonstrated that overall CO SB 2 sb emissions were 64% higher than reported by the industry. [Extracted from the article]