Back to Search Start Over

Artificial intelligence ethics has a black box problem.

Authors :
Bélisle-Pipon, Jean-Christophe
Monteferrante, Erica
Roy, Marie-Christine
Couture, Vincent
Source :
AI & Society; Aug2023, Vol. 38 Issue 4, p1507-1522, 16p
Publication Year :
2023

Abstract

It has become a truism that the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI) is necessary and must help guide technological developments. Numerous ethical guidelines have emerged from academia, industry, government and civil society in recent years. While they provide a basis for discussion on appropriate regulation of AI, it is not always clear how these ethical guidelines were developed, and by whom. Using content analysis, we surveyed a sample of the major documents (n = 47) and analyzed the accessible information regarding their methodology and stakeholder engagement. Surprisingly, only 38% report some form of stakeholder engagement (with 9% involving citizens) and most do not report their methodology for developing normative insights (15%). Our results show that documents with stakeholder engagement develop more comprehensive ethical guidance with greater applicability, and that the private sector is least likely to engage stakeholders. We argue that the current trend for enunciating AI ethical guidance not only poses widely discussed challenges of applicability in practice, but also of transparent development (as it rather behaves as a black box) and of active engagement of diversified, independent and trustworthy stakeholders. While most of these documents consider people and the common good as central to their telos, engagement with the general public is significantly lacking. As AI ethics moves from the initial race for enunciating general principles to more sustainable, inclusive and practical guidance, stakeholder engagement and citizen involvement will need to be embedded into the framing of ethical and societal expectations towards this technology. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
09515666
Volume :
38
Issue :
4
Database :
Complementary Index
Journal :
AI & Society
Publication Type :
Academic Journal
Accession number :
164901216
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-021-01380-0