Healing, Not Prison: Analyzing Mental Health Courts as an Alternative to Prison and as a Method to Reduce Recidivism.

Mental health and drug treatment courts have a substantially positive effect on instances of recidivism in non-violent offenders in the criminal justice system. A significant portion of the prison population in the United States suffers from serious mental illness (SMI); due to the deinstitutionalization of mental health treatment, prisons often end up being the only treatment option for people with SMI or substance abuse disorders. Policy is needed to treat the issues surrounding mental illness instead of punishing them. Incarceration is not the answer for people with mental health problems. Instead of punishment, a restorative model of justice can be implemented in the form of alternative courts that reduce recidivism for non-violent offenders with mental illness. The policy which could accomplish this is the expansion of mental health and drug treatment courts. To argue this point, this policy paper will provide a brief history of mental illness deinstitutionalization and explore the basic problems of mental health and substance abuse for people in the criminal justice system. The paper will summarize the basics of mental health court (MHC) functions and examples of MHCs in action are detailed alongside evidence of their efficacy. Potential opposition and drawbacks are explored, and additional policy recommendations for supplementing MHC programs are presented. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]