Revisiting the weighting function for lightness in the CIEDE2000 colour-difference formula.

We have used 13 experimental datasets (7420 colour pairs) to study the performance of the weighting function for lightness proposed by the CIEDE2000 colour-difference formula, because it has been suggested that this function can be improved by using the weighting function for lightness S_L = 1 adopted by the CIE94 colour-difference formula. Using the standardised residual sum of squares ( STRESS) index, it was found that: (i) replacing the S_L in CIEDE2000 with S_L = 1 improved the results for 7/13 datasets considered, but the improvement was statistically significant only for 1/13 datasets; (ii) a Whittle-type lightness-difference formula can be used to replace the term ∆ L*/ S_L in CIEDE2000, which led to a new colour-difference formula with no statistically significant difference with respect to CIEDE2000 for any of the 13 experimental datasets. A modification of the CIEDE2000 formula using a Whittle-type lightness formula is proposed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]