Reply to comment by S. Neuman on 'Is unique scaling of aquifer macrodispersivity supported by field data?'.

The article presents the authors' reply to S. Neuman's comments which advocates the need for an adequate hydrogeological characterization of aquifers. It provides a brief summary of their work that was overlooked by Neuman's comment which include a critical reexamination of the field data collected by L.W. Gelhar et al especially those referred to as of medium or low reliability and the addition of new data what were again screened for reliability.