Pain tolerance and the thresholds of human sensory and motor axons to single and repetitive bursts of kilohertz-frequency stimulation.

Transcutaneous electrical stimulation with repetitive bursts of a kilohertz carrier frequency is thought to be less painful than conventional pulsed currents by reducing the sensitivity of pain receptors. However, no purported benefit has been shown unequivocally. We compared the effects of carrier-frequency stimulation and conventional stimulation on pain tolerance and the thresholds for sensory and motor axons in twelve participants. The ulnar nerve was stimulated transcutaneously with a conventional single pulse and 5 and 10 kHz carrier-frequency waveforms that had 5 and 10 pulses, respectively, when delivered in bursts of ∼1 ms duration. Phase durations were adjusted across waveform types to match the total charge for a given current amplitude. Single bursts of stimulation were delivered from 1 mA up until no longer tolerable. This was repeated with repetitive bursts of stimulation at 20 Hz for 1 s. Participants tolerated higher current amplitudes with both carrier-frequency waveforms than conventional stimulation, with repetitive bursts more painful than single bursts. However, compared to conventional stimulation, carrier-frequency waveforms required more current to produce sensory and motor-threshold responses and to obtain a maximal motor response (M _max ). When the current at pain tolerance was normalised to the current at M _max , participants tolerated lower stimulus intensities with carrier-frequency waveforms than conventional stimulation. These findings indicate that there is little to no benefit in using carrier-frequency waveforms to minimise the discomfort from electrical stimulation as the increase in stimulus intensity at pain tolerance is more than offset by reduced effectiveness in the activation of sensory and motor axons. KEY POINTS: Transcutaneous electrical stimulation with repetitive bursts of a kilohertz carrier-frequency waveform is thought to be less painful than conventional pulsed currents. For ulnar nerve stimulation, when stimulus waveforms were matched for total phase charge, participants tolerated higher current amplitudes with carrier-frequency stimulation than conventional stimulation. However, compared to conventional stimulation, carrier-frequency waveforms required more current to produce a threshold response in both sensory and motor axons and to produce a maximal motor response (M _max ). When current at pain tolerance was normalised to current at M _max , participants tolerated lower stimulus intensities with carrier-frequency waveforms than conventional stimulation. Carrier-frequency waveforms provide little to no benefit in minimising the discomfort from transcutaneous electrical stimulation as the increase in stimulus intensity at pain tolerance is more than offset by reduced effectiveness in activating sensory and motor axons.
(© 2024 The Author(s). The Journal of Physiology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of The Physiological Society.)