Patient Perception of Medical Student Professionalism: Does Attire Matter?

Introduction: Patient compliance and outcomes have been shown to be influenced by the quality of the doctor-patient relationship. In addition, the effect of physician attire on the patient's perception of the physician has been long appreciated. Data shows that professional attire is preferred by patients. Whereas treating physicians are the backbone of patient management, medical students are often a patient's first encounter in a teaching clinic. Patient perception of the student may impact their rating of the attending physician. Despite this, medical students are often dressed wearing scrubs in surgery clinic. The purpose of this study was to determine if patient perception of medical students would be affected by the students' attire.
Methods: A 7-item, validated professionalism scale was used to survey surgery clinic patients whose initial examinations were performed by a medical student. Students were blinded and randomly assigned to wear professional attire versus scrubs. Patients' responses of 'strongly agree' were compared to lower ratings for each item.
Results: One hundred twenty-three patients completed our survey, 63 (51.2%) wearing scrubs and 60 (48.8%) in professional attire. The average age was 49.7 ± 15.8 years. In the professional attire group, there was no significant association for any of the 7 items. However, in the scrubs group, all 7 items were significant such that a higher proportion of patients under the age of 60 rated medical students wearing scrubs higher than did patients aged 60 and above.
Conclusion: Students in scrubs were perceived to be less knowledgeable, competent, and professional by older patients. In contrast, younger patients seemed unaffected by the dress of medical students in clinic. Older patients may judge the medical community's growing acceptance of more casual attire in the workplace as less professional, potentially affecting patient satisfaction. Surgical educators should require a standard of professional attire for students in clinic.
(Copyright © 2020 Association of Program Directors in Surgery. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)