Targeting PARP-1 and DNA Damage Response Defects in Colorectal Cancer Chemotherapy with Established and Novel PARP Inhibitors.

Simple Summary: Inhibition of the DNA repair protein PARP-1 is a promising concept in cancer therapy. More recently, PARP-1 has been revealed as a possible target in colorectal cancer, which is the second leading cause of cancer-related death worldwide. In this work, we screened a compound library to identify novel PARP inhibitors with low cytotoxicity and tested their efficacy in colorectal cancer cell models with and without defects in the DNA damage response. Furthermore, we evaluated whether the putative PARP inhibitors synergize with chemotherapeutic drugs used in the clinics to treat colorectal cancer patients. Using various experimental approaches, we were able to identify two promising molecules with potent PARP inhibition in colorectal cancer cells without causing cytotoxicity on their own. Moreover, the novel PARP inhibitors sensitized colorectal cancer cells to the anticancer drug irinotecan dependent on homologous recombination deficiency. Remarkably, the clinically approved PARP inhibitor olaparib displayed the strongest synergistic effects, but it was also cytotoxic as a single agent in wildtype colorectal cancer cells. The novel PARP inhibitors might, therefore, be useful for a combination therapy with irinotecan to avoid overlapping toxicity on healthy tissue such as bone marrow, which warrants further preclinical studies. The DNA repair protein PARP-1 emerged as a valuable target in the treatment of tumor entities with deficiencies of BRCA1/2, such as breast cancer. More recently, the application of PARP inhibitors (PARPi) such as olaparib has been expanded to other cancer entities including colorectal cancer (CRC). We previously demonstrated that PARP-1 is overexpressed in human CRC and promotes CRC progression in a mouse model. However, acquired resistance to PARPi and cytotoxicity-mediated adverse effects limit their clinical applicability. Here, we detailed the role of PARP-1 as a therapeutic target in CRC and studied the efficacy of novel PARPi compounds in wildtype (WT) and DNA repair-deficient CRC cell lines together with the chemotherapeutics irinotecan (IT), 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), and oxaliplatin (OXA). Based on the ComPlat molecule archive, we identified novel PARPi candidates by molecular docking experiments in silico, which were then confirmed by in vitro PARP activity measurements. Two promising candidates (X17613 and X17618) also showed potent PARP-1 inhibition in a CRC cell-based assay. In contrast to olaparib, the PARPi candidates caused no PARP-1 trapping and, consistently, were not or only weakly cytotoxic in WT CRC cells and their BRCA2- or ATR-deficient counterparts. Importantly, both PARPi candidates did not affect the viability of nonmalignant human colonic epithelial cells. While both olaparib and veliparib increased the sensitivity of WT CRC cells towards IT, no synergism was observed for X17613 and X17618. Finally, we provided evidence that all PARPi (olaparib > veliparib > X17613 > X17618) synergize with chemotherapeutic drugs (IT > OXA) in a BRCA2-dependent manner in CRC cells, whereas ATR deficiency had only a minor impact. Collectively, our study identified novel lead structures with potent PARP-1 inhibitory activity in CRC cells but low cytotoxicity due to the lack of PARP-1 trapping, which synergized with IT in homologous recombination deficiency. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]