Commentary on Dick Blackwell's paper on 'The dialectics of Chat in online large groups'.

This article examines the use of Chat in online large groups and its various implications. It presents different perspectives on Chat, including its role as part of the social unconscious, a counter-culture, or a liberated zone. The author emphasizes the importance of considering personal emotions and power dynamics when deciding whether to allow Chat in large groups. The article also addresses the inequalities that exist within these groups and the potential for marginalized voices to be heard through Chat. It raises questions about the political significance of Chat and the need for further understanding of its dynamics. Additionally, the article discusses technical considerations and the accessibility of Chat in online groups. It explores the challenges and dynamics of participating in both spoken and written communication in a large group setting, questioning whether the expectation for members to engage in both forms is a form of ableism or ageism. The text also acknowledges the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and global protests against racism on the group's discussions, emphasizing the importance of addressing racism, colonial guilt, and inequality within the group. In conclusion, the article recognizes the value of the chat function and the potential for further exploration and development in online group analysis. [Extracted from the article]