More Than a Natural Function.

Allison Yarrow's book, "Birth Control: The Insidious Power of Men Over Motherhood," examines the politics and misconceptions surrounding childbirth in America. The book criticizes the medical system for unnecessary interventions and blaming women for complications, while also promoting the natural childbirth movement. However, the book's claims about childbirth safety and the role of doctors are challenged by rising rates of maternal and infant mortality, highlighting the importance of access to medical care. The natural childbirth movement's critique of medical authority is valid, but its empirical claims and assumptions about women can be questionable. The field of obstetrics has evolved, with more women entering the profession and evidence-based practices improving maternal care. While the book raises important issues about mistreatment of women in childbirth, it overlooks the complexities of modern obstetrics and the need for comprehensive medical care. The natural childbirth movement emphasizes the rejection of pain relief during labor, but its opposition to pain relief and idealization of natural childbirth can be prescriptive and judgmental, creating unrealistic expectations for women. It is important to recognize that women are not just vessels for reproduction, but thinking and feeling individuals who deserve competent medical attention and respect during childbirth. [Extracted from the article]