Back to Search Start Over

Conceptual replication study of fifteen JDM effects: Insights from the Polish sample .

Authors :
Sobkow, Agata
Surowski, Marcin
Olszewska, Angelika
Antoniewska, Nina
Barcik, Katarzyna
Bartkiewicz, Urszula
Brzeska, Agnieszka
Brzozowska, Adrianna
Budrewicz, Oliwia
Choja, Jakub
Choma, Kamila
Chorbotowicz, Patrycja
Filimoniak, Michalina
Filip, Łukasz
Gambuś, Paweł
Gierlik, Weronika
Gonczar, Tomasz
Goryczka, Katarzyna
Góra, Maksymilian
Haczek, Marta
Source :
Polish Psychological Bulletin. 2022, Vol. 53 Issue 3, p138-151. 14p.
Publication Year :
2022

Abstract

We conducted pre-registered replications of 15 effects in the field of judgment and decision making (JDM). We aimed to test the generalizability of different classical and modern JDM effects, including, among others: less-isbetter, anchoring, and framing to different languages, cultures, or current situations (COVID-19 pandemic). Replicated studies were selected and conducted by undergraduate psychology students enrolled in a decision-making course. Two hundred and two adult volunteers completed an online battery of replicated studies. With a classical significance criterion (p < .05), seven effects were successfully replicated (47%), five partially replicated (33%), and three did not replicate (20%). Even though research materials differed from the originals in several ways, the replication rate in our project is slightly above earlier reported findings in similar replication projects. We discuss factors that may underlie replication results (success vs. failure). We also stress the role of open science practices such as open data, open research materials, pre-registration, and registered reports in improving the replicability of results in the JDM field. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
00792993
Volume :
53
Issue :
3
Database :
Academic Search Index
Journal :
Polish Psychological Bulletin
Publication Type :
Academic Journal
Accession number :
160102793
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.24425/ppb.2022.141862