A novel unstructured performance-based task of executive function in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.

Objective: Executive functions (EFs) have been assessed with performance-based measures and rating scales. Research has shown a lack of association between these two methods. One factor that might contribute to this difference is the structure provided on performance-based measures that is not provided on rating scales. This study examined the role of structure on self-directed task completion, an aspect of EF, using a novel unstructured performance-based task (UPT). Method: Children aged 8–12 years (38 attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, ADHD; 42 typically developing) and their caregivers participated. We compared performance on the UPT, performance-based measures of EF (Stroop test and Trail-Making Test), and a rating scale to assess EF (Barkley Deficits in Executive Functioning Scale–Children and Adolescents, BDEFS–CA). Results: Group differences were found across all measures. Significant associations emerged between the UPT and Stroop test, Trail-Making Test, and BDEFS–CA, but no significant associations were found between the Stroop test or Trail-Making Test and the BDEFS–CA. In regression analyses, performance-based tasks and the rating scale both uniquely predicted UPT performance. The UPT was a significant predictor of group status when entered with performance-based tasks, but the UPT did not enter as a significant predictor when entered with the rating scale. Conclusion: The UPT is a promising measure to assess self-directed task completion in children with ADHD. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]